**Ranking the Ghostbusters Movies: A Journey Through the Spirit World**
Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire may have stumbled out of the gate at the box office, but it has ultimately exceeded expectations by grossing over $100 million in the U.S. alone, indicating that there's still a pulse in this beloved franchise. While some may categorize this as the fourth installment of Ghostbusters, it’s essential to recognize that it’s technically the fifth, as Paul Feig’s reboot must also be factored into the conversation. Critics have had their reservations about Gil Kenan’s contribution, yet it appears that fans are genuinely enjoying the film, particularly because it gives the original Ghostbusters more significant roles. This pondering led me to rank the Ghostbusters films, and I’m sharing my list here. I anticipate that this will ignite some discussions, so please share your thoughts in the comments – even if you vehemently disagree! Just a heads-up, this ranking starts from least favorable to most favored.
**Ghostbusters (2016):**
Let me clarify something right from the outset: my feelings towards Paul Feig’s female-led reboot are not as negative as many others have voiced. In fact, I remember this film sparking one of the hottest debates on JoBlo. When I provided a somewhat positive review, I was met with an avalanche of angry emails that lasted for years! It still amazes me how that spark of controversy continues even now, with random YouTube comments insisting, "We can’t trust this guy because he liked Feig’s Ghostbusters." However, despite my not-so-harsh viewpoint, I admit it was an ill-conceived idea. I’m baffled as to why Sony thought a remake of the iconic original, featuring an all-female ensemble, could escape scrutiny, especially when the surrounding conversation became so politically charged. I truly believe the film might have performed better if it had stayed within the established Ghostbusters universe. The cast, including Kristen Wiig, Melissa McCarthy, Kate McKinnon, and Leslie Jones, do their utmost with the material, and Chris Hemsworth adds comedic flair as their bumbling secretary. Ultimately, though, it felt like a lost cause from the outset.
**Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire (2024):**
In my review, I gave Frozen Empire a rating of 6 out of 10, but I might have been a bit too harsh. I was dragged to see it by some die-hard Ghostbusters fans earlier this week, and I found myself genuinely enjoying the experience – especially in a theater full of enthusiastic viewers. Do I see it as a cinematic triumph? Not entirely; there’s quite a bit of world-building that detracts from the pacing. However, I found Dan Aykroyd’s expanded role to be quite moving, and witnessing the original Ghostbusters come together again at the film’s conclusion truly pleased me.
**Ghostbusters 2 (1989):**
For years, many fans labeled this sequel as inferior, but I believe that’s an unfair assessment. While it may not quite reach the heights of its predecessor, it features some genuinely wonderful moments. The film's initial third is particularly engaging, showcasing the now down-on-their-luck Ghostbusters as they struggle to make ends meet, with Bill Murray masterfully portraying Venkman’s evolution into a subpar TV psychic. I particularly appreciated the realism of Venkman’s run-down New York City apartment, littered with empty beer bottles, a poignant portrayal of his emotional state post-Sigourney Weaver’s Dana. I’ve certainly had my share of similar experiences. However, the decision not to bring back Elmer Bernstein for the score was a significant misstep. I can't help but think that if it had incorporated the classic Ghostbusters themes, audiences might have embraced it much more warmly. Additionally, the romantic subplot between Rick Moranis’s Louis and Annie Potts’ Janine adds a delightful layer to the narrative.
**Ghostbusters: Afterlife (2021):**
One reason I found Afterlife so appealing is that director Jason Reitman brilliantly captured the right tone, instilling a genuine sense of threat while blending it seamlessly with a nostalgic, American Graffiti-meets-Ghostbusters vibe. The film's ending, which features a touching reunion with Egon’s ghost, resonated with me on an emotional level, and I truly consider this installment to be underrated. If you're aiming to reboot a beloved series while introducing fresh characters and still honoring longtime fans, this film serves as a prime example of how to do it right. The performances from Paul Rudd, Carrie Coon, Finn Wolfhard, and Mckenna Grace are admirable additions to the Ghostbusters legacy. And let’s not overlook Olivia Wilde’s cameo, which adds another layer of excitement!
**Ghostbusters (1984):**
Now, it should come as no surprise what my pick for the ultimate Ghostbusters film is: the original 1984 classic! This film is nothing short of a masterpiece, striking an exquisite balance between humor and horror that has influenced countless imitations, none of which could replicate Ivan Reitman’s magic. The score is exceptional, the soundtrack is iconic, and the cast is nothing less than phenomenal. Bill Murray, Dan Aykroyd, Harold Ramis, Ernie Hudson, Rick Moranis, Sigourney Weaver, William Atherton, and Annie Potts all deliver unforgettable performances. And I can’t forget the classic Stay Puft Marshmallow Man's antics! If you haven’t experienced this film in a theater yet, I highly recommend seizing any chance to watch it with an audience; it’s truly a magical experience. I still cherish the memory of catching a screening at TIFF one year, with Bill Murray in attendance!
So there you have it! How do your rankings for the Ghostbusters series stack up? What are your thoughts? I’m eager to hear your insights in the comments!
